The Rev. Lesser left in November, 1962. The Rev. Charles Erickson was made vicar then. He and his wife bought the vicarage in September, 1975.
In July, 1977, the last payment was made on the mortgage of the church buildings and on January 15, 1978 the Rev. Charles Erickson and the Right Rev. C. Kilmer Myers (then Bishop of California) burned the mortgage.
St. Peter's by-the-Sea became a parish in the Diocese of California.
The porch canopy was added and the commemorative stained glass panels were added later. An opportunity arose to purchase two dwellings and a storage building that backed up to the parish property and fronted Napa Avenue. Church members subscribed to sufficient loans to purchase the property.
The Reverend Erickson retired and, after a search process, the parish called the Reverend Joseph Patronik who became the second rector in January, 1992. He served until March of 1994.
After a prolonged search with a lot of time devoted to determining the wishes of the parishoners, St. Peter's called the Reverend Harriet B. Linville. She commenced her service on February 25, 1996.